Why a ZEC ETF May Not Be a Good Idea for Zcash

Eric Van Tassel, a user on X (Twitter), argues that a ZEC ETF is fundamentally incompatible with Zcash’s purpose.

“I hope ZEC never gets one, as once that happens, an asset is no longer decentralized,”
Eric said, calling ETFs “a Trojan horse.”

Eric’s critique is not about ETFs as financial instruments; it is about the control structures they create. Unlike spot trading on crypto exchanges, ETFs concentrate influence among Wall Street firms that make trading, market-making, and custodial decisions.

For a privacy coin, that concentration is existential.

“An ETF effectively means that an asset value will be highly influenced and controlled by Wall Street,” Eric warned.

SEC filings show the Grayscale Zcash Trust controls about 2.4% of ZEC’s circulating supply, already giving the asset one of the highest institutional concentrations among privacy coins. Converting the trust to an ETF would further expand its influence.

Sponsored

Sponsored

The crypto industry has already seen the downside. When the Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) converted to an ETF in January 2024, redemptions created intense sell-side pressure. The general sentiment is that a similar redemption wave could hit Zcash.

Data reinforces this concern, showing markets still remember the days when GBTC outflows repeatedly pushed Bitcoin lower. Eric argues those dynamics are no accident.

“The recent dump was influenced by these giant institutions that now control many of these assets… Their ultimate goal is to either destroy crypto or completely control it as a part of their CBDC agenda,” he added.

Meanwhile, the Grayscale Zcash Trust is already flashing warning signs.

• NAV/Share: $42.59
• Market Price: $35.05
• Discount: approximately 18%

Sponsored

Sponsored

Such a steep discount shows shareholders may be anticipating further price pressure, or at least are unwilling to pay full value for assets that may soon face ETF-linked selling pressure.

The trust currently manages $205.7 million, charges a 2.5% expense ratio, and has 4.83 million shares outstanding. High fees and regulatory ambiguity may explain why investors expect turbulence ahead.

Why Zcash Has Outperformed, And Why That Might End

Despite regulatory headwinds, ZEC has significantly outperformed several major altcoins in recent months. Critics argue this is precisely because it is not yet under ETF control, leaving its price action more organic and less susceptible to institutional flows.

“The fact that Zcash does not currently have an ETF might be a good reason why Zcash has been moving so well,” Erin noted.

He even speculates that Bitcoin’s ETF-driven structure has capped its upside:

Sponsored

Sponsored

“I see $140,000 to $150,000 max out of Bitcoin this cycle… Money will roll into the assets that these ETFs don’t control,” he indicated.

The SEC, not the Electric Coin Company (which develops Zcash), will determine the fate of the Zcash ETF. If approved, it would mark the first-ever ETF tied to a major privacy coin, potentially rewriting the regulatory path for similar assets.

But the implications go beyond policy. Zcash was built for financial privacy amid a surveillance era.

The question now is whether that mission can withstand the gravitational pull of Wall Street, or whether, as critics warn, an ETF would transform ZEC from a decentralized, privacy-focused tool into a tightly managed institutional asset.

Perhaps, these fears explain why Zcash’s ZEC token is only up by a modest 0.7% in the last 24 hours despite Grayscale’s expressed interest.